As WWE NXT New Year’s Evil draws near on January 6, 2026, speculation is growing about familiar WWE faces making their comebacks during this much-anticipated event. The upcoming show is likely to feature several returns, setting the stage for new storylines as WWE NXT heads into the new year.
Anticipation Builds for Big Names at NXT New Year’s Evil
WWE NXT New Year’s Evil is poised to mark the return of several stars who have left the company or have been absent from television for some time. Fans are looking forward to possible surprise entrants as the event signals the start of new feuds and shifts in the NXT roster.
1. Indi Hartwell Possible Comeback
Indi Hartwell, who previously made an impression as part of the crossover between TNA and NXT, is generating significant buzz. With TNA Wrestling preparing for its AMC Network debut on January 15, there is considerable speculation that Hartwell may return to the WWE stage at this flagship event. Known for her fan-favorite status, Hartwell’s addition would fill a gap among the NXT babyfaces and provide strong rivalry opportunities, especially with Blake Monroe and Jordynne Grace. A comeback could also see Hartwell striving for a second reign as NXT Women’s Champion in 2026.
2. Recent Departures Eye WWE Return
Aside from Hartwell, several wrestlers who have left WWE in the past year are rumored to be considering a return to NXT. Bringing back established performers adds depth to the roster and introduces exciting matchups against emerging talent.
3. Absent Stars Expected to Reappear
Other key NXT figures who have been missing from television for months may use the New Year’s Evil event as a platform for their re-entry. Their presence could refresh storylines and surprise both their former rivals and the NXT audience.
4. Cross-Promotion Talent Integration
The event’s timing coincides with increased collaboration between wrestling organizations, like TNA’s growth and AEW activity. Crossover stars, who have previously appeared or worked with NXT, could be set to return, making the night even more unpredictable.
5. Surprise Appearances from Award-Winning Performers
As award winners from the previous year are recognized, there is potential for some titleholders or nominees to make stand-out returns. These appearances could reignite past rivalries or create fresh contenders in the NXT championship scene.
6. Return of Former Champions
Former NXT champions remain a focal point for returning talent. Their re-emergence at WWE NXT New Year’s Evil could alter the title picture dramatically and draw attention to the brand as 2026 begins.
Overall, the buzz surrounding WWE NXT New Year’s Evil is intensifying as fans anticipate several high-profile comebacks. The expected returns of names like Indi Hartwell and other notable WWE or TNA personalities promise to shape the direction of NXT in 2026, ensuring an action-packed start to the year and renewed excitement for wrestling enthusiasts.
