Pro Wrestling Illustrated has released its 2025 Top 500 list, naming WWE Champion Cody Rhodes as the number one wrestler. Known as the “American Nightmare,” Rhodes earned this recognition after a period marked by his championship reign and prominence within WWE.
Criteria Behind the Rankings and Evaluation Period
The rankings cover the period from August 1, 2024, to July 31, 2025, assessing wrestlers on several factors including in-ring achievement, influence in the industry, technical ability, competitiveness, and activity level. Each wrestler needed at least 10 singles matches (or six across separate months) during this timeframe to qualify.
2025’s Top 10 Wrestlers According to PWI
Following Rhodes at the top, AEW’s Jon Moxley secured the second position, maintaining his status as a dependable main event talent. WWE’s Gunther placed third, recognized for his dominant performances. The rest of the top 10 features prominent names who have demonstrated considerable success and impact this year.
“THE 35TH ANNUAL #PWI500
Buy digital/preorder print (in stores 10/14)https://t.co/B4sbESJ5q0
Top 10 Wrestlers:
1. @CodyRhodes
2. @JonMoxley
3. @Gunther_AUT
4. Adam Page
5. @510njpw
6. Jey @WWEUsos
7. @swerveconfident
8. @WWERollins
9. @caristicomx
10. @WillOspreay pic.twitter.com/DxOE4pkoMa”
— PWI (Pro Wrestling Illustrated)
Significance of Rhodes’ Placement and Future Expectations
Cody Rhodes’ top ranking underscores his role as the face of WWE during a challenging and competitive year within professional wrestling. His consistent championship defenses and high-profile matches have solidified his standing. As the industry continues to evolve, the results of PWI 2025 highlight shifts in prominence among leading figures across WWE and AEW.
THE 35TH ANNUAL #PWI500
Buy digital/preorder print (in stores 10/14)https://t.co/B4sbESJ5q0
Top 10 Wrestlers:
1. @CodyRhodes
2. @JonMoxley
3. @Gunther_AUT
4. Adam Page
5. @510njpw
6. Jey @WWEUsos
7. @swerveconfident
8. @WWERollins
9. @caristicomx
10. @WillOspreay pic.twitter.com/DxOE4pkoMa— PWI (Pro Wrestling Illustrated) (@OfficialPWI) September 23, 2025
