The ongoing uncertainty within WWE’s Judgment Day faction has sparked speculation that Dominik Mysterio could revive the group’s fortunes by bringing back Vickie Guerrero as their manager, a scenario that would mark Guerrero’s first WWE appearance in 89 months. This potential move brings the Dominik Mysterio WWE Judgment Day manager discussion to the forefront, as backstage chaos mounts and new leadership becomes increasingly vital.
Chaos Grows Within Judgment Day Faction
Judgment Day, once recognized as a dominant presence across WWE’s main roster, now finds itself ensnared in conflict. Liv Morgan’s absence and Finn Balor’s attempts to establish himself as the group’s primary leader have escalated the instability in recent weeks. Tensions are high, with infighting and anarchy threatening to unravel the faction’s influence in the company.
As battles for control continue, speculation has centered on how Judgment Day might find a way forward. Dominik Mysterio, now 28, has emerged as a possible catalyst for change, with rumors pointing toward a major shift in the faction’s direction.
Vickie Guerrero’s Imminent WWE Return?
Reports indicate Vickie Guerrero may soon return to WWE, as noted by her ringside appearance during SmackDown on September 13, 2024. Guerrero’s last involvement dates back to 2018, when she competed in the Women’s Royal Rumble Match. Now, speculation suggests she could rejoin WWE at the upcoming Evolution event on July 13, ending an 89-month absence from the company.

Dominik Mysterio’s connection to Guerrero has historic roots. Their bond traces back to his involvement in a memorable storyline with Vickie’s late husband, Eddie Guerrero, in 2005. In recent years, Dominik’s embrace of Eddie’s distinctive mannerisms in his current villain persona only strengthens the narrative. Adding Vickie Guerrero as Judgment Day’s manager would not only reference this legacy but potentially offer new creative possibilities for the faction.
The unpredictable energy within Judgment Day has provided fertile ground for this possibility. With internal strife mounting, introducing Guerrero as manager could reset the group’s structure, allowing RAW’s prominent stable to head in a fresh, yet familiar direction.
Questions Linger Over Dominik Mysterio’s Standing
Amid these rumors, Dominik Mysterio’s role in Judgment Day faces its own uncertainties. The young superstar has appeared unsettled, as Finn Balor distances him from Liv Morgan and manipulates faction alliances. Balor, in his campaign for control, has involved Roxanne Perez in the broader power dynamics, further complicating relationships within the group.
Although some have speculated that Finn Balor might be plotting to expel Dominik from Judgment Day, recent developments cast doubt on this theory. Instead, Balor seems to be maneuvering to consolidate his influence and potentially establish a version of Judgment Day tailored to his leadership style. With Morgan now out of the picture, Balor has drawn ever closer to his goal of redefining the group’s direction.
How Dominik Mysterio will respond to these power shifts remains unknown. The next several weeks are expected to determine his path within the faction and whether new management under Guerrero—or any other adjustment—will solidify his role or loosen his ties further.
Potential Impact of Vickie Guerrero’s Comeback
The prospect of Vickie Guerrero taking on the WWE Judgment Day manager role holds significant implications for the company and the intricate web of relationships among its stars. Guerrero’s return could energize the RAW brand, providing new narrative fuel for a faction badly in need of stability, and engaging audiences with nostalgia and fresh drama alike.
Still, it is essential to note that the scenario of Guerrero managing Judgment Day remains speculative for now. WWE has not confirmed her return or revealed whether her presence at the upcoming Evolution event will be a one-time appearance or mark a consistent on-screen role. Until more details emerge, speculation will continue to swirl—and with so many players involved, every appearance and maneuver in coming weeks will be closely watched.