JD McDonagh confronted Dominik Mysterio after being overlooked on WWE RAW, stepping up to face Rusev instead of Mysterio who had initiated the conflict. The latest developments revealed mounting tensions within The Judgment Day faction, as McDonagh openly challenged Mysterio for failing to support him during the match, despite being at ringside. This situation highlights growing discord in the group that could spark major changes soon.
Strained Relations Emerge During WWE RAW Match
With Finn Balor refusing to take on Rusev, the bout between McDonagh and Rusev became official on RAW, placing McDonagh in a difficult position. Dominik Mysterio was present near the ring but notably did nothing to assist McDonagh, who bore the brunt of the fight alone. This lack of backing did not go unnoticed, as McDonagh expressed his frustration openly after the event.
In a pointed social media post, McDonagh criticized Mysterio for his inaction, addressing him directly by tagging his account and sarcastically noting,
“Two belts and he can’t hit him with either one? Some muchacho.😔 @dominik_35”
. This comment highlighted his disappointment with Mysterio’s failure to leverage his championships to aid his teammate.
In response, Dominik Mysterio reacted subtly by commenting with a gif referencing Cedric Diggory from Harry Potter, indicating that he was observing the situation. Yet, this minimal response suggested persistent friction among the group’s members, casting doubt on their unity.

Potential Breakup Brewing Within The Judgment Day Faction
The tension unfolding between JD McDonagh and Dominik Mysterio may be symptomatic of deeper conflicts within The Judgment Day. Reports have hinted that Finn Balor has been distancing himself from Mysterio since WrestleMania, where Mysterio claimed the Intercontinental Championship by pinning Balor. Expectations were that Balor would accept this outcome smoothly, but the reality appears more complicated.
Liv Morgan’s injury had initially interrupted any plans for dramatic shifts within the faction, but WWE seems intent on positioning Dominik Mysterio as a singles competitor. Holding titles in two separate promotions, Mysterio’s push as a solo star could intensify existing rivalries.
McDonagh’s recent remarks reinforce the idea that internal goodwill has eroded, raising the prospect that he and Finn Balor might abandon the faction to concentrate on their title runs as a tag team. The ongoing friction points to an impending implosion for The Judgment Day, potentially reshaping WWE storylines.
What This Means for WWE Storylines Moving Forward
The unfolding drama surrounding JD McDonagh and Dominik Mysterio signals a critical moment for WWE’s narrative arcs. With alliances fraying and champions poised to redefine their paths, fans can expect significant shifts ahead. McDonagh’s outspoken challenge to Mysterio not only exposes fractures within The Judgment Day but also builds anticipation for future encounters that could lead to faction splits and evolving rivalries.
This internal strife may alter the dynamics of upcoming WWE events, compelling viewers to watch how these top talents navigate their conflicts and whether new partnerships form. As Dominik Mysterio embarks on his singles career, the interactions among these wrestlers will likely shape the next chapters in their professional journeys.
