WWE star Tiffany Stratton commented publicly on the AEW return of Tay Melo, capturing the attention of both wrestling fans and insiders Wednesday night. The moment arrived as Stratton offered a striking online reaction after Melo’s highly anticipated reappearance for the Jacksonville-base promotion following a lengthy absence, ensuring that the phrase
“Tiffany Stratton comments on AEW return of Tay Melo”
became a trending topic.
Tay Melo, previously recognized as a major up-and-coming talent in wrestling, made her first appearance on AEW television in more than two years. She had last competed in January 2023 before stepping away on maternity leave. Despite having been cleared to return in 2024, it took until this edition of Dynamite for AEW to finally book her comeback. Melo made an immediate impact upon her reentry, intervening to protect Anna Jay from Megan Bayne and Penelope Ford during a heated segment, leading to an exuberant reaction from the crowd.
Fans React to Tay Melo’s Surprise Appearance
The unexpected nature of Melo’s return set off a buzz throughout the wrestling community. Tay Melo’s dramatic arrival sparked cheers from those in attendance, and she leveraged the moment by sharing a visually stunning photo to mark her comeback on Instagram. It was this post that caught Tiffany Stratton’s eye.
Stratton, who has been the reigning WWE Women’s Champion for several months leading up to Money in the Bank, took to social media and delivered a simple yet emphatic response: “Wooooowwwww,” she wrote, succinctly summing up the general mood among many fans — Tiffany Stratton’s comments on AEW return of Tay Melo have now spread widely among both WWE and AEW audiences.
Wrestling Veteran Dutch Mantell Critiques Tiffany Stratton and Charlotte Flair
Debate about Stratton’s star quality has not been limited to fan circles, as wrestling veteran Dutch Mantell shared pointed views in a recent episode of BroDown. Mantell weighed in on the potential of both Tiffany Stratton and Charlotte Flair, expressing skepticism about their standing and contributions within the company.
”Well, who is the star? She [Tiffany] is not. She is not in that star role, and Charlotte Flair, I think, she’s getting worse. I don’t know what they [have] got in store for her, but when she talks, you can hear the same stuff as a shoot in the dressing room. That’s what you’re basically (…) that’s what you’re hearing. But I don’t see how that can draw money. I really don’t,” he said. —Dutch Mantell, Wrestling Veteran
According to Mantell, neither Stratton nor Flair currently holds true “megastar” status, and the direction for both women remains unclear. His candid comments reflect a broader skepticism about how WWE is managing top female talent, questioning whether their presentation will translate to greater success or fan interest.
Looking Ahead for Stratton and Melo
As for Tiffany Stratton, speculation continues about how long she will hold onto the Women’s Championship, especially with the division’s shifting dynamics and outside critiques. Tay Melo’s surprise AEW return, meanwhile, has signaled her readiness to play a larger role after her time away from the ring, injecting renewed energy into the roster.
With both Stratton and Melo now under the spotlight, fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how each athlete’s journey unfolds — and how those journeys might influence the evolving landscape of women’s wrestling in the months ahead.
