Cody Rhodes, often known as The American Nightmare, faces growing speculation about a shift in his persona following his recent WWE title loss, raising questions about a possible Cody Rhodes character change. The dramatic defeat to Drew McIntyre during the high-stakes Three Stages of Hell match on SmackDown has fans and insiders buzzing about what might be next for one of WWE’s most talked-about superstars.
Unexpected Turn in Fan Support During Historic Showdown
The year did not start as planned for the former Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. In a much-anticipated Three Stages of Hell match, Rhodes faced the formidable Scottish competitor Drew McIntyre on a recent SmackDown episode, ultimately losing his championship. Unlike previous matches where fan loyalty had firmly backed Rhodes, there was a notable shift this time as supporters rallied behind McIntyre, eager to see him begin the year as champion.
Speculation Over Rhodes’s Heel Turn Intensifies
Rumors about Cody Rhodes turning heel have swirled for months, with many predicting that his defeat to McIntyre might mark the beginning of a darker turn. Observers noted that Rhodes’s in-ring demeanor and reactions during the loss to Drew McIntyre hinted at an evolving character, laying the groundwork for a potential transition into a more antagonistic role within WWE. Despite the mounting anticipation among fans yearning for this change, recent news from Cory of Bodyslam.net suggests there is no concrete plan for Rhodes to officially turn heel at this time. However, Cory hinted that such a character evolution could arise organically, influenced by what unfolded in his grueling match against Drew McIntyre.
New Rivalry on the Horizon After Title Setback
Rhodes, often regarded as one of WWE’s top stars, now faces uncertainty as to his next steps after coming off a major title loss. According to recent developments, a scenario where he wins the Men’s Royal Rumble again seems unlikely in the current climate. Instead, the aftermath of his defeat has set the stage for what could be an intense new feud with Jacob Fatu. Fatu played a pivotal role by interfering in the match and launching an assault on Rhodes, a move that hints at the beginning of a high-profile rivalry between the two competitors. This storyline is poised to bring a fresh dynamic to the SmackDown roster and could lead to major matches in the weeks ahead.
Outlook for Cody Rhodes and WWE Storytelling
The fallout from Cody Rhodes’s title loss has stirred emotions among his supporters, heightening intrigue around his next character direction. While no official confirmation of a heel turn exists, the organic shifts observed in his recent performances keep fans and industry watchers on edge. The anticipated clash with Jacob Fatu may provide the perfect stage for Rhodes’s character to develop further, ensuring that the WWE audience remains captivated by every twist in his journey on the blue brand.
Not a turn but a character shift
— Cory of Bodyslam.net (@Cory_Hays407) January 9, 2026
