Jade Cargill, a rising star on WWE’s SmackDown brand, continues to face criticism despite her undeniable physical presence and talent inside the ring. Since making her WWE debut in late 2023 after nearly three years with All Elite Wrestling (AEW), she has drawn attention—both positive and negative—as she aims to establish herself as a leading figure in women’s wrestling.
Known for her dominance and athleticism, Cargill challenged Tiffany Stratton for the Women’s Championship at SummerSlam but fell short. Critics frequently question her in-ring experience, often labeling her as inexperienced or “green.” Additionally, some controversy surrounds her social media remarks and backstage conflicts, which have added to the scrutiny she currently faces.
How Jade Cargill Responded to Backlash by Comparing Herself to Roman Reigns
Jade Cargill spoke candidly about the criticism during a recent appearance on The Babyfaces Podcast, drawing parallels between her journey and that of WWE superstar Roman Reigns. She noted that, much like Reigns, who endured widespread fan disapproval early in his career before becoming one of the company’s most beloved stars, she believes time will eventually shift public opinion in her favor.
Reflecting on her four years in the industry, Cargill emphasized the impatience fans have for immediate success and recognition, especially when top-tier opportunities are granted quickly. She stated,
“I’m four years and some change now in this industry and I think the other person I think had the less amount of time was Bianca (Belair) and I think she was 11 years in the game, and people want things so quick and so fast because I’ve been pushed to the moon because I’m gonna be a star and people see that. People used to say stuff about Roman (Reigns). Now, everybody loves Roman.”
—Jade Cargill, WWE Superstar
This comparison highlights her belief that patience and perseverance are key to overcoming early criticism and gaining long-term fan support. Cargill also recalled encouragement from AEW peer Bryan Danielson, who praised her confidence in the ring despite her limited experience, underscoring her natural ability and determination to improve rapidly.
Challenges Surrounding Jade Cargill’s Rise in WWE
Cargill’s journey has not been without tension backstage. Following her viral social media comment about being
“surrounded by wolves in the shape of women,”
she received backlash from fellow female wrestlers. This amplified existing rifts, including a reported backstage altercation with former WWE star Shayna Baszler related to in-ring miscommunication.
These incidents contribute to the narrative about her needing to grow and adjust within WWE’s locker room dynamics. Despite these complications, Cargill’s role on SmackDown remains prominent, with recent segments featuring her in confrontations and storylines involving Tiffany Stratton, Kiana James, and Women’s United States Champion Giulia.
Jade Cargill’s Background and Career Highlights
Before her WWE tenure, Jade Cargill gained recognition in AEW, where her rapid ascent was notable for its pace and impact. She holds two tag team championships in the Stamford-based promotion and was victorious in WWE’s Queen of the Ring Tournament at Night of Champions, achievements that underscore her potential as a decorated competitor.
Her athleticism and ring presence make her a standout talent, even as she continues to refine her craft and face scrutiny over her relative inexperience. Industry observers often highlight her physical advantages but stress the importance of honing technique and storytelling skills in the ring to build a lasting career.
Industry Context: Recent Developments in Professional Wrestling
While Cargill focuses on solidifying her position, the wrestling world is abuzz with other notable shifts. Vince McMahon’s possible return to WWE, multiple contract renewals involving AEW’s multitalented performers, and contract expirations for WWE President Nick Khan and select stars have kept the scene dynamic. Speculation also surrounds potential dramatic storylines for veterans like Seth Rollins, and backstage tensions involving figures such as Triple H have drawn interest.
These surrounding developments contribute to an environment of change and opportunity, highlighting how wrestlers like Cargill must navigate both competition and internal politics within the industry.
Looking Ahead: What Jade Cargill’s Future Might Hold
Jade Cargill’s self-comparison to Roman Reigns reflects her confidence that public opinion will evolve in time, allowing her to emerge as a top fan favorite. Her talent, combined with her drive to grow and overcome early setbacks in WWE, suggests she could shape a compelling and influential legacy in women’s wrestling.
As she continues to engage in high-profile matches and storylines on SmackDown, fans and critics alike will be watching closely to see if Cargill’s predicted transformation into a beloved figure will come to fruition. Her next steps, both in-ring and backstage, could define her career trajectory alongside some of wrestling’s most esteemed stars.
