JD McDonagh’s return to WWE television has been postponed, with fans unlikely to see him wrestle at the Elimination Chamber or in the weeks leading up to WrestleMania 42. According to recent updates, his comeback is now set for around WrestleMania in the spring.
Recovery Progress and Official Updates on McDonagh’s Status
During a January 26, 2026 Q&A session, WrestleVotes confirmed that McDonagh will not be returning soon.
“He’s not coming back anytime soon, not the next couple of weeks or Elimination Chamber. So it’s right around WrestleMania, the Spring time.”
This aligns with previous reports signaling his prolonged recovery from injury.
McDonagh shared a photo in December 2025 from a hospital bed, revealing a bandage on his right hand or wrist, suggesting he underwent surgery. His last WWE match took place in November 2025 on WWE RAW, where he was defeated by Rey Mysterio, marking the beginning of his hiatus.
Judgment Day Storyline Addresses McDonagh’s Absence
To explain his absence, the Judgment Day faction incorporated it into their storyline, with Dominik Mysterio telling Liv Morgan and Roxanne Perez that Finn Balor had gone to check on McDonagh. Balor later took to social media to provide reassurance:
“I just got home this very second from checking on my dear friend [JD McDonagh] & I can confirm that he is in good spirits & will make a full recovery.” ?Finn Balor, WWE Superstar
WWE’s Approach to McDonagh’s Recovery and WrestleMania Season
Revealed by Wrestling journalist Dave Meltzer, WWE granted time off to several Superstars ahead of Royal Rumble and WrestleMania to facilitate proper healing. McDonagh was among those listed, appearing to be in a post-operation phase as the company prioritized his health over rushed returns.
With the confirmation that McDonagh will not appear before the Elimination Chamber and is expected to return only near WrestleMania, fans must brace for a wait until spring to see him back in action with Judgment Day.
Looking Ahead to McDonagh’s Comeback and Its Implications
The delay in JD McDonagh’s WWE return adds an element of uncertainty to upcoming storylines, as Judgment Day must progress without his involvement for several more months. His eventual return near WrestleMania 42 could provide a significant boost to WWE’s spring programming, injecting fresh energy into ongoing narratives.
Wrestling fans and insiders alike will be watching closely to see how McDonagh reintegrates into the roster after his rehabilitation, with his health and performance remaining top priorities.
