Mariah May WWE NXT debut reactions from AEW and WWE stars poured in following her high-profile appearance, as she stepped into the NXT ring and made her intentions clear to the audience and her competition. The former AEW competitor immediately drew attention on her first night, confronting Jacy Jayne and declaring her desire to pursue the Women’s Championship, prompting widespread support from across both wrestling promotions.
Mariah May Draws Praise and Encouragement From AEW Peers
After making her mark on NXT, Mariah May shared a celebratory post online, featuring herself with the caption “honey, i’m home,” tagging both WWE and NXT. This post quickly attracted reactions from several of her former All Elite Wrestling colleagues. Deonna Purrazzo responded with enthusiastic clapping, expressing her support silently but clearly, while Austin Gunn added his own endorsement with an expressive emoji. Penelope Ford congratulated May, and Toni Storm—once a notable rival in AEW—joined by simply liking the post.
These gestures from her AEW peers, including prominent names like Toni Storm, Deonna Purrazzo, Austin Gunn, and Penelope Ford, reflected a shared respect for Mariah May’s transition into WWE and highlighted the interconnectedness of the professional wrestling community.
Main Roster WWE Superstars React to Mariah May’s Debut
While Jacy Jayne and her group were far from welcoming on NXT TV, Mariah May received plenty of positive energy backstage and online from WWE’s main roster superstars. In response to her Instagram photo, stars such as Liv Morgan and Charlotte Flair dropped strings of excitement-filled emojis to mark the occasion. Chelsea Green and Kelani Jordan both offered her a warm welcome in the comment section, and Jessica McKay—formerly known as Billie Kay in WWE—joined in to share her enthusiasm about the new arrival.
Additionally, prominent figures like Morgan, Flair, and Bayley showed their support by liking Mariah’s post, reinforcing that her appearance did not go unnoticed among top WWE talent. The sense of camaraderie was evident, bridging both current and former WWE personalities.
Potential Changes Ahead for Mariah May in WWE
Shortly after her impactful debut, reports began circulating that Mariah May may undergo a name change within WWE NXT, following a trend seen with other former AEW stars joining the roster. Ricky Saints, previously known as Ricky Starks during his AEW tenure, underwent a similar transition upon joining NXT earlier this year. This possible change could mark another chapter in May’s evolving wrestling persona as she establishes herself in the new environment.
Mariah May’s shift from AEW to WWE continues to draw attention not only for her in-ring ambitions but for the cross-promotional support she has received. As she sets her sights on the NXT Women’s Championship, her warm reception highlights her growing influence and hints at major storylines to come in WWE’s women’s division.
