Toni Storm recently shared her surprising perspective on the infamous pie-throwing episode that played a significant role in ending her WWE career. As a current four-time AEW Women’s World Champion, Storm’s success in All Elite Wrestling contrasts sharply with her earlier wrestling experiences in WWE.
Storm’s rise in AEW has been marked by immense popularity and multiple title defenses throughout 2025, including victories over prominent competitors like Megan Bayne, Mariah May, Mina Shirakawa, Athena, and Mercedes Mone. Yet her time on WWE SmackDown is often remembered chiefly for one incident involving Charlotte Flair.
How a Cream Pie Led to a Turning Point in Storm’s WWE Journey
During her WWE run, Toni Storm was publicly humiliated on SmackDown when Charlotte Flair threw a cream pie in her face. Although Storm retaliated by pieing Flair back the following week, the event garnered extensive attention and preceded Storm’s sudden decision to leave the company, taking a flight home from a show shortly thereafter. Despite the controversy surrounding it, Storm herself does not seem bitter about the episode.
On the Marking Out podcast, when asked about the pie incident, Storm described it as a memorable highlight of her WWE tenure:
“That was the most exciting thing I ever got to do really, when you think about it. The rest was just random wrestling.” —Toni Storm, Professional Wrestler
Toni Storm’s Current Dominance in AEW and Future Challenges
In contrast to her WWE past, Toni Storm has embraced the identity of being “Timeless” in AEW, a persona that has resonated strongly with fans. She is set to defend her title in a high-profile four-way match at the upcoming All Out event, underscoring her status as a top competitor in the women’s division. Her recent defenses against notable contenders indicate a continued dominant presence in the promotion.
Contextualizing the Incident Within Toni Storm’s Wrestling Career
The cream pie episode remains a notable moment from Storm’s WWE days, but her departure and subsequent success in AEW highlight a turning point rather than an end. This event and her reflections on it illustrate how singular moments can impact a wrestler’s career trajectory and public perception. Toni Storm’s positive attitude toward the incident underscores her resilience and growth as a performer.
