Why Adam Cole should return to WWE is a question gaining traction as his run in All Elite Wrestling enters its next phase, with his current position raising discussions among fans and insiders alike. As the wrestling world waits to see where his career will go after his AEW contract ends, key shifts in WWE and AEW have made the idea of a main roster comeback more compelling than ever.
Adam Cole’s Journey: From NXT Spotlight to AEW Challenges
Adam Cole made his final appearance for WWE at NXT TakeOver 36 in August 2021, where he was defeated by Kyle O’Reilly in a Two-out-of-Three-Falls contest. Soon after, Cole debuted at AEW All Out 2021, teaming with The Elite—Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks. During nearly three and a half years with AEW, Cole has achieved notable milestones, including his current reign as TNT Champion and the formation of the Paragon stable alongside Roderick Strong and Kyle O’Reilly.
Despite these highlights, Adam Cole’s time in AEW has been marked by hurdles. Injuries have disrupted his momentum, and many observers, including wrestling pundits and a vocal fanbase, feel his potential has not been fully realized. Suggestions have emerged that he has become lost in the shuffle, prompting further debate on whether WWE might offer him the renewed focus he needs.
Triple H’s Influence and Opportunity for Main Roster Stardom
Adam Cole was a prominent figure during WWE’s NXT black-and-gold era and was handpicked by Triple H to lead The Undisputed Era, holding the NXT Championship for 403 days. With Triple H now in charge of WWE creative and the company experiencing record-breaking success, there is widespread belief that returning now could position Cole as a top main event contender, a role he never had on WWE’s main roster during his first stint.
His impact in NXT extended beyond those who regularly watched the developmental brand, with fans on the main roster also recognizing his charisma and in-ring ability. His classic matches against Johnny Gargano remain memorable milestones, but his profile has diminished in AEW due to questions around booking direction and consistency.
Comparisons with Former AEW Stars Who Have Thrived in WWE
Cole’s entire WWE tenure to date was spent in NXT, which, while a highlight of the developmental brand’s history, left unanswered what he could achieve on the main roster. In contrast, other former AEW talents like Cody Rhodes and Penta have transitioned to WWE and found significant success, suggesting that Cole could follow a similar trajectory if he made the jump now.
Fan enthusiasm remains strong for Cole’s return, especially after witnessing previous AEW stars thrive under Triple H’s vision. It seems the timing could be ideal for him to pursue fresh opportunities and larger audiences in WWE’s current creative environment.
Main Reasons Why Adam Cole Should Return to WWE Now
Why Adam Cole should return to WWE centers on several factors. First, his status as a favorite of Triple H provides him a pathway to main event status and creative investment. Second, the WWE main roster offers exposure and rivalries he has yet to experience. Third, his diminished prominence in AEW—despite moments such as his rivalry with MJF and leadership of Paragon—suggests that WWE’s revitalized product might rejuvenate his career.
Cole’s present contract with AEW, which runs through 2027 as confirmed by Tony Khan, means that any potential move is some years away. Nonetheless, fans are eager to see him potentially face high-profile opponents like Seth Rollins and Cody Rhodes upon a possible WWE return. Each of these factors contributes to the sense that, when the time comes, a WWE comeback would be both timely and transformative for Adam Cole’s career.
What the Future Holds for Adam Cole and the Pro Wrestling Landscape
As Cole continues his AEW run, the complexities and opportunities within both major promotions are shaping his legacy. His journey has included alliances with Roderick Strong, Kyle O’Reilly, and stars like Kenny Omega, experiences as both a champion and leader, and memorable rivalries. The next phase—whether it involves a return to WWE or further cementing his name in AEW—will influence not only his path but also the broader competition between organizations like WWE and AEW. Whatever comes next for the Panama City Playboy, the wrestling world will be watching closely as these major developments unfold.
