The debate surrounding the Roman Reigns WrestleMania main event is more intense than ever as WWE approaches its biggest night of the year. Although Reigns’ presence is certain to draw views, a closer look at current circumstances reveals compelling reasons why he should not headline WrestleMania 42 in 2025.
As one of wrestling’s most recognizable figures, Reigns has dominated headlines and main events for years. Yet, speculation suggests he might face Drew McIntyre for the Undisputed WWE Championship at WrestleMania 42, aiming to reclaim a title he has previously expressed interest in. While on paper the matchup appears high-profile, there is little narrative substance supporting this direction. McIntyre, recently crowned champion after an exhausting Three Stages of Hell battle, has had history with Reigns but no ongoing story. Suggestions that WWE wants to revive McIntyre’s “Bloodline Hunter” storyline do not seem to mesh with current character paths or company momentum.
Lack of Existing Rivalry Weakens Main Event Potential
Unlike previous years, Roman Reigns and Drew McIntyre are not currently engaged in any storyline that would naturally culminate at WrestleMania. Reigns, known as The Tribal Chief, is currently entangled in a heated conflict with The Vision faction, a storyline that escalated during their clash at Survivor Series. His team’s defeat in that Men’s WarGames match did not involve McIntyre, underscoring the lack of buildup for a match between the two at WWE’s biggest event.
Additionally, Reigns’ position as a part-time competitor further complicates the situation. His infrequent appearances can undermine any lengthy storyline, making meaningful weekly development nearly impossible. Launching a drawn-out feud between these two stars would require consistent involvement—something Reigns’ current schedule and health limitations make unlikely.
There is also the question of plausibility for McIntyre’s “Bloodline Hunter” return. McIntyre, fresh off a long and grueling campaign to the top, would look out of place suddenly rekindling an old rivalry for the sake of the main event. This scenario risks presenting McIntyre as reactionary rather than as a decisive champion, weakening a character that fans have supported through many setbacks and triumphs.
Audience Fatigue and WWE’s History with Roman Reigns
For years, one of the audience’s largest complaints was WWE’s insistence on Reigns as the company’s centerpiece, regardless of fan sentiment. When Reigns won the 2015 Royal Rumble,
“the audience responded with boos despite him getting an assist from The Rock.”
This negative reaction persisted despite repeated attempts to frame him as the conquering hero, especially in headline matches against Brock Lesnar at various Premium Live Events (PLEs).
Although the “Tribal Chief” persona brought a wave of renewed popularity for Reigns, fans are now showing signs of weariness again. His sporadic television appearances and extended absences mean that any main event match can feel disconnected from WWE’s ongoing stories. A title match against McIntyre, which would likely involve another short reign for The Scottish Warrior, risks repeating the disappointing booking patterns of the past—denying fans the payoff of a true McIntyre victory and reign they have long demanded.
Recent reports have suggested alternatives, such as a trilogy-ending clash between Reigns and Cody Rhodes. This matchup would have greater narrative continuity and offer a fresh twist for WWE WrestleMania 42. As of now, however, forcing Reigns into the headline role appears to run counter to fan sentiment and logical storytelling alike.
What Lies Ahead for WWE and Its Top Stars
The decision about who should headline WWE WrestleMania 42 will shape ongoing storylines and determine fan engagement for the remainder of the year. While Reigns’ drawing power is undeniable, the absence of an organic rivalry with McIntyre, his irregular in-ring schedule, and shifting audience moods mean his participation in the main event could do more harm than good. If WWE wants to capitalize on momentum and reward its dedicated fanbase, exploring new narratives—perhaps centered on Cody Rhodes or elevating other deserving talent—may bring much-needed freshness and excitement to the showcase event.
