After Piper Niven’s recent break from WWE due to neck issues, the future of her spot in Chelsea Green’s Secret Hervice has become uncertain. Niven had played a key role in the faction while also showcasing her comedic talents. With her extended absence now confirmed, the group must find a new member to maintain its momentum in WWE programming.
Piper Niven WWE replacement is a pressing topic among fans and officials alike, as Chelsea Green has even requested potential candidates to submit resumes. This article examines five possible WWE stars who could step into Niven’s position in the Secret Hervice and what they could bring to the faction’s dynamic.
Izzi Dame Brings Size and Strength as Potential Heavyweight
One critical trait that set Piper Niven apart was her impressive size, offering a powerful presence that Chelsea Green could lean on to dominate opponents despite Niven’s record of mixed match outcomes. Izzi Dame, currently part of the Culling faction, could fill the large, muscular role that Niven left behind. Standing nearly as tall as Charlotte Flair, Dame provides a commanding figure in the ring and has experience working as the enforcer for Kiana James before James moved to the main roster last year. Her addition would give Green a reliable partner comparable in size to stars like Raquel Rodriguez.
Ivy Nile’s Untapped Potential Could Shine in a New Role
Among WWE’s RAW roster, Ivy Nile has been underutilized in recent months despite carrying the fierce nickname “The Pitbull” for her aggressive style. Originally, her involvement with American Made was meant to boost her standing, but since Chad Gable’s injury, she has appeared infrequently on television. Free from ongoing storylines, Nile could transition over to SmackDown as the quieter yet formidable muscle for the Secret Hervice. Her smaller frame paired with raw intensity might offer a fresh dynamic that echoes Niven’s silent toughness.
Karmen Petrovic Offers Martial Arts Skills and Shared Nationality
The current Secret Hervice members, Alba Fyre and Piper Niven, share Scottish nationality, adding a unique identity to the faction. If WWE wants to continue with this international flavor, newcomer Karmen Petrovic from NXT fits the bill as a Canadian performer with striking martial arts expertise. Petrovic balances in-ring skill with a reserved persona, making her a fitting replacement who would not overshadow Chelsea Green’s character. She has also briefly interacted with Green in recent NXT segments, indicating potential chemistry for faction storytelling.
Nikkita Lyons Could Bring Athleticism and Fresh Energy
Nikkita Lyons, a standout with a martial arts background similar to Lola Vice, has yet to find a prominent place on NXT programming, partially due to two serious knee injuries. Lyons possesses notable physical gifts and a versatile offense featuring kicks and varied strikes. Given her lack of current storylines amid a crowded NXT women’s roster, WWE might leverage Lyons’ skill set and charisma by elevating her as the newest member of the Secret Hervice. This move could lead to an evolving character arc, possibly even positioning Lyons as a contender to rival Green herself in the future.
Natalya’s Veteran Experience Could Stabilize the Faction
Natalya, a seasoned WWE veteran from Canada, has seen limited television time recently, despite WWE’s attempt to pair her with Maxxine Dupri as a tag team. After Dupri appeared solo on a recent RAW asking General Manager Adam Pearce for a match opportunity, Natalya’s absence has become notable. Known for her strong, hard-hitting ring style and no-nonsense persona, Natalya would bring credibility and experience to the Secret Hervice if shifted to SmackDown. Her inclusion could also help anchor the group’s mix of personalities and styles.
As Chelsea Green’s faction faces change, choosing a Piper Niven WWE replacement is critical to sustaining the momentum and maintaining fan interest. Each candidate brings distinct qualities, from raw size and aggression to martial arts proficiency and veteran savvy. This rebuilding phase presents WWE an opportunity to refresh the Secret Hervice’s identity while keeping Green’s outlandish character in focus. The coming weeks should reveal who steps into this role and how the faction evolves in WWE’s competitive women’s division.
