When WWE signed Jade Cargill to a long-term contract, the company quickly placed her on the main roster, bypassing their developmental brand, NXT. WWE likely aimed to capitalize on Cargill’s recent status as AEW’s TBS Champion and showcase a high-profile signing immediately. This swift promotion, however, has sparked discussions about whether it was the best path for her career development.
Concerns Over Cargill’s In-Ring Readiness and Training
During a recent Duke Loves Rassling podcast, former wrestler D-Von Dudley criticized WWE’s decision to forgo NXT for Cargill. He argued that she missed out on crucial conditioning and training that NXT provides before performing on the main roster. Dudley explained,
“She had never been in NXT, and that was a mistake. Maybe she should have gone to NXT first. If she had gotten that training before going to the main roster, we probably wouldn’t even be having this conversation.” – D-Von Dudley
This conversation emerged amid reports that several wrestlers sustained injuries during matches with Cargill, raising questions about her in-ring skills and preparedness.
Why NXT Could Have Made a Difference for Cargill’s Development
Dudley acknowledged WWE’s desire to push Cargill’s striking look and physical presence, but emphasized that skipping developmental experience led to complications. He mentioned,
“I understand that she has the look and the physique, but bringing her straight from AEW to the main roster was not the right move. If you look at her time in AEW, there’s a good chance she really needed that time in NXT. It wouldn’t have hurt her to spend some time there, get proper training, and then move up to the main roster.” – D-Von Dudley
His perspective suggests that NXT’s rigorous training and conditioning could have better prepared Cargill for high-profile matches and protected fellow performers.
Upcoming Challenges for Jade Cargill at WrestleMania 42
Jade Cargill is scheduled to defend her WWE Women’s Championship against Rhea Ripley at WrestleMania 42 this April. This defense will be only her second televised title defense since beginning her reign last November. The outcome and quality of this match could significantly impact perceptions of Cargill’s standing in WWE.
Implications for WWE’s Talent Development Strategy
The debate over Jade Cargill’s transition raises broader questions about WWE’s approach to integrating talent from outside promotions like AEW. While fast-tracking athletes with star potential can boost short-term attention, insufficient foundational training may undermine performance quality and locker-room safety. How WWE balances these priorities could influence the future success of wrestlers crossing over and the company’s overall product strength.
