After a seven-year break from wrestling, during which he ventured into UFC fights, acting, and comic book projects, Phil Brooks, known as CM Punk, made a high-profile return to professional wrestling with All Elite Wrestling (AEW). His comeback in 2021 occurred amid considerable legal troubles, including a lawsuit against a WWE doctor that Punk ultimately won, and a fallout with longtime friend Colt Cabana resulting in a separate settlement. Despite these complications, the combined allure of AEW’s rising popularity and the financial backing of AEW president Tony Khan brought Punk back to the ring, setting the stage for a volatile relationship.
The Clash of Personalities and Management Challenges in AEW
CM Punk’s return was marked by friction rooted in his difficult reputation and the laid-back culture cultivated by The Young Bucks, integral players in AEW’s backstage environment. Punk’s confrontational style clashed with the promotion’s culture, making it challenging for Tony Khan to maintain harmony amid egos and tensions. The situation was reminiscent of past wrestling promotional challenges, where figures like Vince McMahon managed to juggle strong personalities such as Hulk Hogan, Steve Austin, and Ultimate Warrior to deliver compelling product despite backstage difficulties. Unlike McMahon’s firm control, Khan struggled to balance the diverse temperaments under his management, culminating in escalating conflicts.
The Fallout: Backstage Fights and Departures
The tension boiled over when a backstage altercation involving CM Punk, Ace Steele, and members of The Elite surfaced, linked to circulating rumors that allegedly stemmed from The Young Bucks leaking bad blood with Colt Cabana in wrestling media. Punk was sidelined for nearly a year due to a triceps injury requiring surgery, but the situation deteriorated further after the infamous “real glass” incident involving Jack Perry. Another backstage fight soon followed, which resulted in Punk’s dismissal from AEW. This marked the inevitable conclusion of a professional relationship fraught from the start.
It’s clear that the Punk-Khan partnership was unlikely to survive long-term, as their fundamental differences were irreconcilable. While criticisms can be made of both parties, the reality is that AEW needed a functional dynamic that never materialized. The immaturity displayed by Jack Perry accelerated this breakdown, playing a partial but significant role in the departure of AEW’s biggest star.
Jack Perry’s Role in the Punk Departure
Jack Perry’s involvement in backstage drama complicated CM Punk’s tenure. For instance, Perry reportedly referenced the incident where Punk denied him permission to use real glass during a televised event—a detail that fueled backstage animosities. Had Perry avoided such provocations, Punk might have remained with AEW through his contract, providing financial justification for his salary despite injury layoffs. Instead, Perry’s unprofessional conduct contributed to an environment where Punk’s dismissal became inevitable.
The Business Impact of Losing CM Punk
CM Punk’s presence in AEW had a noticeable positive impact across multiple metrics. While Punk was on the show Dynamite, weekly viewership consistently hovered around a million, but after his departure, numbers dipped below 640,000. His drawing power was visible in live event attendance, which declined sharply, forcing the promotion to resort to smaller venues and even darkened arenas to disguise empty seats. Merchandise sales driven by Punk also sustained revenue streams that have continued since his WWE return. Despite stable pay-per-view buy rates, Punk’s departure left a tangible void in AEW’s commercial performance.
Jack Perry’s Return: A Puzzling Decision
In contrast, Jack Perry’s return to AEW in 2024 raised eyebrows given his prior misconduct and minimal impact. After the backstage feud with Punk culminated at Wembley Stadium and a suspension, Perry spent several months wrestling for New Japan before rejoining AEW. His comeback as a heel and brief TNT Championship reign failed to significantly resonate with fans, many of whom followed the controversies surrounding him. Perry’s return was met with indifference from much of the audience, signaling a lukewarm reception to the “scapegoat” persona he adopted.
Reviving the Past: Luchasauras Reunion and Career Questions
At All Out in 2024, Perry’s reintroduction involved reviving the Kill Switch tag team under a new name, Luchasauras, in a move to restore his standing after the CM Punk incident. While this reunion aims to rehabilitate Perry’s image by leveraging nostalgia, it prompts several questions regarding the strategic value of this decision. Is there enough potential in Perry to justify prolonged investment, and does channeling Luchasauras’ career toward supporting Perry come at a cost to both performers? Though this might offer Perry a second chance to build rapport with fans, it risks stagnating his growth and limiting the future prospects of the team.
Potential Paths Forward for Jack Perry and AEW
The success of Perry’s current run depends largely on whether this tag team comeback evolves into something fresh and meaningful. It represents an opportunity for Perry to shed his prior gimmick of a carefree “Jungle Boy” and mature into a serious fan favorite. However, reverting to outdated characters or relying on nostalgia could hinder this growth. It remains uncertain if Perry can truly restart his AEW career or if the decision to bring him back will weigh negatively on Luchasauras and the company’s trajectory.
Comparing Fates: WWE’s CM Punk vs. AEW’s Jack Perry
While WWE features CM Punk as one of its marquee stars, with record profits and expansive distribution, AEW’s reliance on reviving old tag partnerships like Luchasauras signals a differing trajectory. The stark contrast in their drawing power and audience engagement exemplifies why the two companies face unequal success in ticket sales and venue scale. Punk’s departure left a costly gap for AEW, and Perry’s return has yet to show signs of closing that divide.
What Lies Ahead for AEW and Its Talent?
In light of these developments, AEW faces important choices regarding roster management and character development. The ongoing challenge is balancing talent egos and cultivating new stars capable of elevating the promotion’s profile. Jack Perry’s rocky history and contentious return highlight the difficulties of navigating backstage politics and fan expectations. Whether AEW can transform these struggles into a sustainable blueprint for growth remains unclear, but the impact of past missteps looms large over the company’s future.
Your opinions and feedback are welcome. Join the conversation on Twitter @PWMania and Facebook.com/PWMania.
