The next WWE SmackDown event, scheduled at Allstate Arena in Chicago, Illinois, will feature John Cena, a much-anticipated appearance that fans are looking forward to. However, rumors hint that this could mark Cena’s final performance on the blue brand, as he is expected to shift exclusively to RAW after this show.
The possibility of Cena’s departure from SmackDown has led to discussions about who might fill the void he leaves behind. This article explores five possible replacements poised to make an impact if Cena’s rumored exit is confirmed.
Rising Star Tony D’Angelo Poised for Main Roster Debut
Tony D’Angelo has consistently impressed backstage with his performances in NXT, where he held the North American Championship and is famously the only wrestler to have pinned Oba Femi. Reports from insiders JoeyVotes and TC reveal that conversations about calling up the 30-year-old to the main roster are underway.
With John Cena’s expected SmackDown farewell, WWE might introduce Tony D’Angelo to the blue brand, trusting his talent to carry the show forward and replace the role left by The Franchise Player.
Rey Mysterio’s Possible Return Could Energize the Brand
Rey Mysterio has been notably absent from WWE television since his last match on the April 18, 2025 SmackDown episode, only making appearances at live events, including one in Mexico City. Given the current uncertainty surrounding Cena’s future on SmackDown, Mysterio could be ready to make a full return to the blue brand.
As a fan favorite with a significant following, the Master of 619 might be an ideal candidate to step up as a replacement, offering experienced leadership and excitement to the audience.
Ilja Dragunov Could Make a Triumphant Comeback
Ilja Dragunov has been sidelined due to an injury sustained in September of last year, leaving fans eagerly awaiting his return. Recent updates from PWInsider suggest that Dragunov is either fully recovered or very close to being cleared for in-ring action.
Should these reports hold true, Dragunov’s introduction to the SmackDown lineup would be timely, strengthening the roster as John Cena possibly takes his final bow on the show.
Otis’s Return Would Bring Fresh Energy to SmackDown
Otis, after a hiatus from WWE, has appeared in the AAA promotion alongside Omos, but his last televised WWE match saw him lose to Rusev on May 5, 2025, on Monday Night RAW. Since then, he has disappeared from TV without a clear return date.
Instead of bringing Otis back to RAW, WWE’s leadership, particularly Triple H, may opt to have him join SmackDown. Otis’s loyal fan base and vibrant personality could make him a strong contender to fill the gap left by Cena’s departure.
Tama Tonga’s Comeback Could Enhance Storyline Dynamics
Tama Tonga has been away due to injury while his allies continue to engage in the My Family Tree (MFT) faction storyline alongside Solo Sikoa on SmackDown. If he has recovered fully, his reintroduction could add depth and intrigue to current narratives.
Bringing Tama Tonga back to the blue brand, especially within the ongoing MFT storyline, might position him as a credible and engaging replacement for John Cena on SmackDown.
What’s Next for WWE SmackDown After Cena?
John Cena’s rumored exit from WWE SmackDown marks a significant moment for the brand, requiring fresh stars to step into the spotlight. Tony D’Angelo, Rey Mysterio, Ilja Dragunov, Otis, and Tama Tonga each offer unique potential to keep the show compelling and competitive.
The return of these wrestlers or the debut of rising talent will likely influence storylines and fan engagement in the coming months, shaping the future landscape of SmackDown as it adjusts to life without The Franchise Player.
