Friday, December 26, 2025
-5.7 C
New York

3 AEW Stars Poised to Replace Jon Moxley in Death Riders After All In 2025 Shakeup

Published:

Jon Moxley, a prominent AEW star and leader of the Death Riders since August 2024, has been under the spotlight for many months as the faction’s centerpiece. The group has controlled the narrative through a strategic numbers advantage, attracting growing fan interest despite earlier skepticism. However, following the upcoming All In event, this dynamic appears set to change dramatically. The AEW World Championship will be contested in a Texas Death Match between Moxley and Hangman Page, in what the company is promoting as a historic showdown at Globe Life Field Stadium.

Potential Shift in Power: Hangman Page’s Rising Faction

Hangman Page has assembled his own troop consisting of the Opps, Swerve Strickland, and Will Ospreay, building strong momentum ahead of the title match. Fans are widely expecting the Cowboy to complete his redemption arc by capturing the AEW World Championship. Additionally, the return of notable figures like Jay White, Cope, Sting, and Darby Allin may contribute to this anticipated upset. If Page succeeds, it could mean that Jon Moxley will no longer exit the arena as AEW’s reigning champion.

Possible Expulsion of Moxley and His Replacement within Death Riders

Should Jon Moxley lose the championship, it is speculated that the Death Riders may remove him from leadership. Several AEW talents are viewed as potential candidates to fill the vacancy left by the Purveyor of Violence. The faction’s future storylines could be reshaped significantly based on who assumes control after All In.

Jon Moxley
Image of: Jon Moxley

Keith Lee: The Limitless Star’s Anticipated Return

Keith Lee, known as the Limitless star, has been absent from AEW for over eighteen months due to injury but has recently hinted at his readiness to return through social media posts. Before his hiatus, Lee was recognized for his power, leadership skills, and influence within the promotion. Fans and insiders expect that if Lee returns, he could make a big impact by ambushing Moxley and potentially joining the Death Riders as a new force. While Lee has teased playing a villainous role, AEW has yet to showcase him as a heel, making his comeback an intriguing prospect for the faction’s direction.

Gabe Kidd as a Fierce Successor

Another contender for Moxley’s spot is Gabe Kidd, an NJPW star who played a crucial role in helping Moxley retain the world title during the Beach Break Dynamite edition against Samoa Joe. Known for his fearless and aggressive style, Kidd’s recent appearances on AEW programming have enhanced his profile within the Death Riders faction. His alignment with the group could offer fresh energy and intensify their dominance moving forward.

A Potential Leadership Role for the IWGP Global Heavyweight Champion

The current IWGP Global Heavyweight Champion is also considered a strong candidate to lead not only the Death Riders but influence the AEW locker room overall. His dedication to professional wrestling and strong principles align closely with the ethos Jon Moxley has represented. This connection hints at a natural transition of authority that could maintain the faction’s prominence and toughness following Moxley’s departure.

Eddie Kingston’s Possible Return to Guide the Death Riders

Eddie Kingston, known as the Mad King, has not been featured on AEW television since May 2025 but maintains a well-documented friendship with Jon Moxley. Post-All In, Kingston might return to advise Moxley to relinquish his leadership temporarily, possibly positioning himself as the faction’s new head. Such a development would bring a fresh and unpredictable edge to the Death Riders story, leveraging Kingston’s unique intensity and persona.

Anticipation Builds for the Aftermath of All In: Texas

The upcoming All In event promises to be a critical juncture in AEW history, particularly regarding the Death Riders and Jon Moxley’s role within it. With intense rivalries, unexpected alliances, and possible leadership changes looming, fans are eager to witness how these narratives unfold. This shakeup could redefine the faction’s identity and signal a new era in AEW’s evolving landscape.

“The Limitless star has been absent from AEW for over one and a half years. Before the injury, he was portrayed as a powerhouse, a great leader and influencer.” —Unattributed
“He also said that he has been waiting for Tony Khan’s call.” —Unattributed
“Following All In, after Moxley is evicted from the Death Riders, Keith Lee could make his comeback and ambush him.” —Unattributed
“The Limitless star could bring a much-needed change to the Death Riders’ story.” —Unattributed
“Gabe Kidd, a fearless individual, could be a fitting replacement for Jon Moxley.” —Unattributed
“The reigning IWGP Global Heavyweight Champion could be a ruthless leader of not only the Death Riders but also of the AEW locker room.” —Unattributed
“Eddie could be the perfect replacement for Jon Moxley.” —Unattributed
“Death Riders could get riveting with Mad Kingston’s involvement in the group.” —Unattributed
“It will be interesting to see what goes down in the main event of All In: Texas.” —Unattributed

Thomas Schultz
Thomas Schultz
Thomas Schultz is a journalist at CynicalTimes.org, covering the AEW Men’s Division. With one year of experience, he reports on match results, storyline developments, and the rising stars shaping All Elite Wrestling. Thomas brings a fresh perspective and a commitment to accurate, engaging coverage of AEW’s top talent and weekly action. His writing captures the energy, rivalries, and momentum behind one of wrestling’s fastest-growing promotions. From major title bouts to emerging contenders, Thomas keeps fans up to date on everything happening in the AEW men’s roster.
Recent articles
Latest News