Cody Rhodes, a consistent contender in the Royal Rumble, entered the 2026 event with high expectations after notable wins in both 2023 and 2024. Starting at the #11 spot, he lasted close to 37 minutes and eliminated three opponents before eventually being removed from the match. His confrontation with Jacob Fatu, an ongoing rival, was a highlight, but ultimately he was eliminated when Drew McIntyre struck him with a Claymore Kick as he attempted to re-enter the ring.
This early exit surprised many fans and left questions about why Rhodes did not secure another Royal Rumble victory, particularly given his successful history in the event.
Why WWE Chose Not to Crown Rhodes the Winner
Despite Cody Rhodes being viewed by fans as a prime candidate for the Royal Rumble crown, WWE’s creative plans did not include him winning this year. According to insights shared on Wrestling Observer Radio by Dave Meltzer, Rhodes was on a different trajectory leading up to WrestleMania after losing his title to Drew McIntyre on SmackDown in early January.
Cody was no longer champion, had to win either Rumble or Chamber. And Cody was never scheduled to win the Rumble because the nature of the storyline was, is that he had to overcome the adversity and not win the Rumble, and then went into the chamber. Similar story to John Cena last year. [H/T: Ringside News]
The storyline required Rhodes to face adversity by not winning the Rumble but instead advancing through the Chamber event as his path back to contention.
Creative Direction Focuses on Character Development
WWE’s decision to withhold the Royal Rumble victory from Rhodes allowed the writers to frame his journey as one marked by overcoming setbacks rather than straightforward triumph. This approach builds suspense around his path to WrestleMania, creating a narrative where Rhodes earns his opportunity through resilience rather than an immediate title shot.
Roman Reigns ultimately prevailed as the 2026 Men’s Royal Rumble winner, selecting CM Punk as his opponent for WrestleMania, signaling the WWE’s broader storytelling directions and feuds.
Additional Developments Affecting WWE Talent Landscape
Besides Rhodes’ storyline, WWE is experiencing notable shifts with other talents. A performer recently disclosed that their contract will not be renewed, pointing to changing dynamics within the company. Meanwhile, legends such as AJ Styles are expected to return to wrestling, promising continued excitement for fans.
Other individuals connected to WWE storylines and off-screen developments include Jey Uso, who recalled memorable moments with Rhodes during their Fastlane 2023 press conference, and Ava, The Rock’s daughter, whose departure from WWE has drawn speculation about her reasons for leaving the company.
Furthermore, Drew McIntyre, a key figure in the current conflicts, suffered a second attack on SmackDown, intensifying tensions in ongoing rivalries. Meanwhile, Chelsea Green addressed her inability to compete for the AAA Mixed Tag Team Championship due to injury, adding to the list of roster challenges.
Upcoming AEW Dynamite episodes are also expected to feature major title matches, which could shift attention and momentum among wrestling fans in the near term.
The Impact of WWE’s Storytelling Choices on Cody Rhodes’ Career
The decision to sideline Cody Rhodes in the 2026 Royal Rumble highlights WWE’s commitment to layered character arcs that emphasize struggle and perseverance over instant victories. For Rhodes, this approach may deepen fan investment by portraying his eventual success as hard-earned, rather than expected.
This route reinforces professional wrestling’s narrative appeal, where setbacks make subsequent triumphs more compelling. As the road to WrestleMania unfolds, the audience can anticipate how Rhodes will navigate these challenges and whether he will reclaim his spot as a leading title contender.
