Booker T recently made controversial remarks about Jade Cargill‘s transition from AEW to WWE, sparking responses from fellow wrestling talents. The discussion centers on Cargill’s development and achievements within the AEW and WWE environments, amid confusion over her career timeline and performance growth.
Clarifying Jade Cargill’s Career Shift from AEW to WWE
Jade Cargill concluded her tenure with All Elite Wrestling in 2023 before making her WWE in-ring debut at the 2024 Women’s Royal Rumble Match. Since joining WWE, she has been prominently featured, achieving notable success including tag team gold with Bianca Belair and winning the Queen of the Ring Tournament. Despite recent setbacks such as losing a Triple Threat Match against Nia Jax and Tiffany Stratton for the Women’s Championship on Friday Night Smackdown, Cargill continues to be a key competitor within WWE.
During commentary on his Hall of Fame podcast, Booker T incorrectly referred to Cargill as “fresh off her AEW run,” and suggested she had not gained significant experience while part of the Tony Khan-led company. This statement sparked confusion among industry peers who pointed out inaccuracies in Booker’s understanding of Cargill’s actual timeline and accomplishments.
Industry Reaction to Booker T’s Comments about Jade Cargill
Fightful Select reports that wrestlers from various organizations expressed bewilderment following Booker T’s remarks, noting she last appeared on AEW television in September 2023. Since then, she has participated in more WWE matches over two years than she did in AEW. Many wrestling professionals found Booker’s claim about Cargill’s limited learning during her AEW run to be unfounded, given her rapid progress and visibility in WWE programming. These reactions underscore the importance of accuracy when discussing a wrestler’s career path, especially from respected veterans like Booker T.
Recap of Jade Cargill’s Final Matches in AEW
Jade Cargill’s last AEW match was at the 2023 Double or Nothing event, where she successfully defended the TBS Championship against Taya Valkyrie. After the match, she issued an open challenge, which Kris Statlander answered, ultimately defeating Cargill and ending both her title reign and her undefeated streak.
Several months later, Cargill returned to challenge Kristen in an effort to reclaim the TBS Championship on the September 15, 2023, episode of Friday Night Rampage. The rematch concluded with Statlander retaining the belt, marking Cargill’s final AEW appearance before transitioning to WWE.
Significance of the Debate and What Lies Ahead for Jade Cargill
The controversy surrounding Booker T’s comments highlights the scrutiny WWE stars face as their transitions between promotions are closely examined. Jade Cargill’s journey from AEW to WWE involves substantial milestones, and dismissing her achievements risks undermining her growth as a competitor. This debate reflects broader tensions in the wrestling community about how performers’ histories and skills are perceived across different companies.
Moving forward, Jade Cargill’s performances in WWE will likely continue attracting attention, with fans and peers watching closely to see how she builds on her early success. As she establishes herself more firmly in WWE’s landscape, clarity regarding her past accomplishments will be crucial to appreciating her full impact in professional wrestling.
