Nia Jax has come under intense scrutiny following her performance on the September 26 episode of Friday Night SmackDown, sparking widespread Nia Jax SmackDown criticism. The triple threat match for the WWE Women’s Championship saw Tiffany Stratton emerge victorious over Jax and Jade Cargill, but an accidental injury and a confusing match finish led to backlash from fans and observers.
Details of the SmackDown Match Incident
During the high-stakes triple threat match, Nia Jax unintentionally slammed Jade Cargill violently onto the steel steps by ringside. This mishap caused Cargill, a former AEW star, to suffer a severe open wound that bled visibly. The match concluded with a puzzling blunder when Jax did not kick out at the two-count, confusing viewers and commentators alike. Although the finish was quickly recovered by the wrestlers, the incident fueled negative reactions from WWE audiences on social media platforms.
Support from Fellow Wrestlers Amid Backlash
As the criticism mounted online, several WWE stars rose to Nia Jax’s defense. Tom Pestock, formerly known as Baron Carbon, openly criticized the harshness directed at Jax, condemning fans for their rude and uninformed comments. Chelsea Green, a former WWE Women’s United States Champion, emphasized Jax’s value in the WWE locker room.
“The internet not knowing that Nia is one of the best is the biggest travesty. We’re lucky to have her as a locker room leader.” — Chelsea Green, WWE Wrestler
Bully Ray Offers Perspective on the Match Confusion
On the Busted Open podcast, veteran wrestler Bully Ray addressed the incident that led to confusion in the SmackDown main event. He pointed out that the botched moment was not solely Jax’s responsibility and explained the context behind her in-ring actions during the match’s climax.
“You see Jade sit on Nia’s chest and hook both of her legs. Nia is looking towards her left, and Nia is looking at Tiffany Stratton. Why is Nia looking at Tiffany Stratton? Because Nia knows that Tiffany is responsible for making the save. Nia realizes that Tiffany is not going to be there in time… Tiffany is definitively late, which puts Nia in a bad position where she has to kick out.” — Bully Ray, Former Wrestler
The Broader Reaction Within WWE Circles
The mixed reactions from fans contrasted sharply with the solidarity shown by WWE colleagues who emphasized the challenges of live performance and the unpredictability inherent in high-pressure matches. Supporters highlighted Jax’s experience and integral role within the locker room, arguing that isolated mistakes should not overshadow her contributions.
Upcoming WWE Events and Related Updates
While the focus remains on the recent SmackDown controversy, WWE continues to build anticipation for other major matches. The upcoming Crown Jewel event will feature a headline clash between John Cena and AJ Styles, stirring excitement among fans.
Additionally, there has been buzz regarding potential Hall of Fame inductees, with speculation about another McMahon possibly joining before Shane McMahon. Other news highlights include a WWE referee addressing a separate botch during SmackDown, and Roman Reigns making a surprise return on WWE RAW, reuniting with original members of the Bloodline faction.
Fans can also look forward to a significant match with Rhea Ripley announced for Crown Jewel, and Dominik Mysterio’s unexpected victory over a three-time champion on WWE RAW. Meanwhile, Alberto Del Rio’s recent return to AAA has raised questions about his future relationship with WWE.
The Rock’s anticipated return to the ring remains a topic of speculation, with veterans in the industry commenting on when the iconic wrestler might compete again for WWE.
Significance of the Nia Jax Incident and Future Outlook
The backlash towards Nia Jax highlights the intense scrutiny WWE performers face, especially during live broadcasts of major events like SmackDown. Despite the criticism, the defense mounted by peers underlines the recognition of the complexities involved in wrestling performances and the value of seasoned talents like Jax. How WWE will address these concerns going forward, and whether Jax’s role within the company will evolve, remain questions for the near future.
Continued support from prominent figures and an ongoing dialogue about respect and accountability within the industry could influence the culture of fan engagement surrounding WWE talent, balancing critique with appreciation for the risks and demands of professional wrestling.
The internet not knowing that Nia is one of the best is the biggest travesty. We’re lucky to have her as a locker room leader.
— CHELSEA GREEN (@ImChelseaGreen) September 28, 2025
