Discussion about Jade Cargill not ready for WWE title match intensified after former WWE employee Tommy Carlucci criticized her current positioning on WWE programming, suggesting the company may be rushing her toward the spotlight too soon. Since Cargill’s arrival on WWE’s main stage, her momentum and recent storylines have sparked debate about her readiness for a title opportunity and the creative direction of her push.
Tommy Carlucci Raises Concerns Over Cargill’s Title Aspirations
Jade Cargill captured attention when she debuted in WWE, impressing both fans and insiders, but her path to singles championship contention remains uncertain. Despite initial high expectations, Cargill has yet to carve out a defining moment in WWE. Her time since WWE Fastlane has seen her shift from expected fanfare to a quieter trajectory, including a win as Women’s Tag Team Champion and ongoing tensions with Naomi regarding Bianca Belair.
On a recent episode of The Coach & Bro Show, Tommy Carlucci offered a sharp critique on WWE’s handling of Cargill’s journey. In conversation with Vince Russon, Carlucci argued that the push for Jade Cargill to enter the women’s title scene is misguided and premature, contrasting her situation with established storylines involving Nia Jax and Tiffany Stratton. Carlucci’s comments reflect frustration with how the company is attempting to position Cargill without giving her more time or pivotal feuds to build credibility.
“They’re trying to get Jade involved with the title. But she is nowhere near ready to have a title match, man. It’s ridiculous, they’re reaching.”
—Tommy Carlucci, Former WWE Employee
Possible Evolution 2 Opponent and WWE’s Event Strategy
Looking ahead, WWE is bringing back its all-women’s event Evolution, scheduled for July 13, reviving the format established in 2018 with stars like Ronda Rousey, Becky Lynch, and Charlotte Flair. While nothing has been made official, industry buzz hints that Jade Cargill could face Charlotte Flair at this high-profile show. Such a match would represent a significant opportunity for Cargill but also intensifies pressure regarding her readiness and the wisdom behind a major push.
Other superstars are being considered for Evolution 2 as well. Karrion Kross has shared that Scarlett Bordeaux could be paired with a former Women’s World Champion, believing she proved herself in a strong house show match earlier this year. These discussions highlight WWE’s focus on delivering memorable moments, but also underline the creative uncertainties and tension among insiders and talent alike.
Recent Developments Shake Up WWE Roster and Creative Landscape
The current environment in WWE reflects broader change and unrest. Chris Jericho, known for his presence in AEW, has been absent since the April 9 show. Meanwhile, the release of R-Truth shocked fans and prompted intense reaction across social media and within the locker room. WWE’s decision-making, said to involve Triple H, has removed veterans like Carlito as well, leaving the roster in a state of flux.
The turbulence extends beyond just high-profile exits. Superstar Jey Uso is set for a major tag team match on WWE Raw, and new talents like Jacob Fatu are voicing support for other emerging company stars, reinforcing both optimism for the future and frustration over how stories are being handled. Roxanne Perez recently shared her emotional reaction after her friend’s WWE release, underlining the personal impacts of these corporate decisions. Within this setting, creative directions on shows and at events like Evolution 2 are drawing strong reactions from fans and insiders alike.
Impact of Cargill’s Push and What Lies Ahead
The debate over whether Jade Cargill is truly ready for a major WWE title match continues to generate tension among fans and the wrestling community, especially as influential voices like Tommy Carlucci question the strategy behind her immediate elevation. With an important showdown potentially on the horizon against Charlotte Flair and speculation around WWE’s next creative moves, Cargill’s career is at a crossroads.
This conversation involving prominent figures such as Tommy Carlucci, Vince Russon, and Karrion Kross highlights the complexities WWE faces as it seeks to balance new talent exposure with established narratives. As Evolution 2 approaches and ongoing roster changes affect the company, the outcome of Jade Cargill’s journey may set a tone for how WWE scouts and pushes future stars, determining whether risk-taking leads to success or fuels further doubts among viewers and insiders.
