JD McDonagh has been sidelined since November 2025 due to injury, and his return to WWE action remains uncertain. According to reports from Fightful Select, he is unlikely to be back before the WrestleMania 42 season, which spans from late March to early April 2026. This projected timeline suggests McDonagh will be absent for several months, further extending his hiatus from in-ring competition.
Widely regarded as one of the most underrated talents in WWE, McDonagh’s absence leaves a noticeable gap in the roster. His potential has been highlighted by fellow wrestlers, including World Heavyweight Champion CM Punk. Punk once stated in an interview,
“If I was off my game and JD McDonagh was at his best, he could easily dethrone me.”
This praise underlines the significant faith placed in McDonagh’s abilities beyond his role in The Judgment Day faction.
Additional Updates on Key WWE Superstars and Events Ahead of the Royal Rumble
As the WWE gears up for the 2025 Royal Rumble event in Riyadh, several other important updates have surfaced. Seth Rollins remains out after undergoing surgery in mid-October 2025 and is not expected to return in time for the Royal Rumble. A Fightful Select report notes,
“He at least claims he won’t be at the Royal Rumble. Most in WWE did not expect him to be physically ready for it.”
There is speculation that Rollins’ comeback might be scheduled for after WrestleMania 42, which once again points to a return in the springtime. His prolonged absence is creating uncertainty around his role in upcoming high-profile storylines.
Expectations for Women’s Royal Rumble and Emerging Talents
The Women’s Royal Rumble match promises to be highly competitive this year, with several returning champions and new contenders vying for the spotlight. Charlotte Flair, the first-ever two-time Women’s Royal Rumble winner, could make history by becoming the first woman to secure consecutive victories. Alongside Flair, the field features former winners such as Asuka, Becky Lynch, Bayley, and Rhea Ripley.
Furthermore, according to PWInsider, Sol Ruca—a standout former NXT North American Champion known for her upset victory against Bayley at Saturday Night’s Main Event—may debut in the Royal Rumble. As one of NXT’s brightest prospects, Ruca’s participation could signal a significant push and add fresh excitement to the match, regardless of whether she ultimately wins.
Pat McAfee’s Anticipated Return to WWE Commentary
Pat McAfee is expected to make a comeback to WWE commentary soon after stepping away due to burnout and other commitments last year. While the exact timing remains undisclosed, the expectation is that he will rejoin the announce team shortly. McAfee had briefly returned for Wrestlepalooza but has yet to resume a full-time role.
Additionally, McAfee recently revealed that Brock Lesnar is scheduled to enter the Royal Rumble, pursuing a historic third victory to tie Stone Cold Steve Austin’s record. The upcoming return of McAfee and Lesnar adds unpredictability and excitement as WWE transitions into its new season of major events.
Uncertainty Surrounding WWE’s Future Storylines
The injury status of JD McDonagh and the prolonged absences of Seth Rollins cast a shadow on WWE’s plans leading into the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania 42. These delays could affect championship narratives and alter the dynamics of upcoming matches. Meanwhile, the anticipation surrounding emerging talents like Sol Ruca and the return of popular figures such as Pat McAfee keeps the WWE universe engaged despite the uncertainties.
With the Royal Rumble set in Riyadh and the road to WrestleMania officially kicking off, WWE faces a critical period to reestablish its star power and maintain momentum. The developments over the next few months will be pivotal in shaping the future of WWE as it approaches its marquee events.
